Community - Forum - View old data

Categories :  

Imperial Japanese Navy

  Index

  • IJN Range Chart

    01. 09. 2010 16:37

TheFaller
out of pure boredomness, i decided to make tests with the IJN gun ranges.

The tests were made with a Fuso, TFC BB1, for the 14'' and lower cal guns, and with a
Yamato, TFC BB2, for the 16.1'' and 18.1''. Crew used consisted of gunners lvl 92-95,
boosted, 110 vets each and maxed experts.
These tests were conducted by firing a total of 6 shells for single and early dual guns (since
they had good accurancy) and a total of 18 shells for the remaining ones. Next, measures
were taken, considering the main dots' distance of a marking range, with the help
of Photoshop and a grid carefully made on it.
Error margin expected is 0,1 of a main dot (which i believe is 1 inch). In a metric scale,
that goes 1-1,2mm

The range of most guns here cannot be taken as absolute, so to say, because IJN
spread
isnt that much astonishing as other nations like UK. In other words, as an example, the
16.1'' 1st set has a range of "x", but because of his spread his range can increase or
decrease 0.5 of a dot, making it "x+0.5" or "x-0.5".

Here are the results so far:


Single Guns




Dual/Tripple DD/CL/CA Guns

src="http://img707.imageshack.us/img707/3718/dualandtripplesmallguns.png">


BB Guns




NOTES:
- longest range of the dual 3'' is 36?(not 50 or 55?. after that angle the range starts
to decrease till 90?
- the single 5.5'' and 6'' are simillar in everything. Main difference is that 6''
trades-off a bit of its range for "more" dmg per shell;
- the 3.9'' and the 5'' duals have basicly the exact same range. Thing is, the 5'' has a
lill worse spread, resulting in some consecutive shells going a bit further away. After
some prolonged shooting and observation, I could basicly agree that they have teoreticly
the same range.


- IJN BB1 and 2 range is lower than US D'=
- the 14''/45 Type 43A N (guns that can Fit in the Kongo) have, interestingly, a better
spread compared to all other BB guns till the yamato!
- 1st set of 16.1'' D guns have a slight better range than the 2nd set. However, since
every 16.1'' have some bad spread, this range can, somewhat, be neglected. Same thing
happens with the Nagato guns (though this range difference cant be neglected).

Hope you IJN guys like it, and find some good use for it :)

**Updates**
- 25/01/10 - Fixed all single gun range, which were wrong; completed the 16.1'' sets, and
added the tripple 6.1'' and 18.1'' guns range; added the remaining N and D guns for the
duals; changed text, and added some notes.
  Index

  • Re : IJN Range Chart

    01. 25. 2010 20:39

UmbralRaptor
Thank you very much. :)

  • Re : IJN Range Chart

    01. 25. 2010 16:12

TheFaller
alright, the "pseudo" final piece of this is over. i wont edit the main post anymore so
soon, cuz i wont be having a SY so soon aswell, and even less the 110 guns.

i didnt made the range test for the single N and D guns, cuz i believe it wasnt that
necessary, and it was already getting bored, cuz i had to remade all tests for all guns
because the ammount of shots made before werent enough to make a precise average. This is
the most perfect as it can be,i can say that :D

if, nonetheless, ppl wants the N and D ranges on singles, ill gladly do it..... here in a
1 or 2 months x_X

not asking much, but if it got unpinned, could some1 pls pin it? :D

  • Re : IJN Range Chart

    01. 21. 2010 19:31

UmbralRaptor
Er, could you rephrase that? I'm having a hard time parsing that post.

  • Re : IJN Range Chart

    01. 21. 2010 18:41

tlc1668
The range is pretty far but for me i could consider the us but still not too far.

  • Re : IJN Range Chart

    01. 20. 2010 20:42

UmbralRaptor
You could be silly and add torpedo ranges. =D

  • Re : IJN Range Chart

    01. 20. 2010 20:35

TheFaller
alrighty, im gonna keep with this thread anyways, cuz ill be editing it only once more.
Just waiting for my BO to increase its marking lines. Smth like more 20 or 30 experts. In
the end, it will be left to test the SY 100 and 110 set guns, which i wont do soo soon <_<

Updates to be made:
- remaking grid for 1 unit at a time
- finishing the BB3 to 4 range measures
- adding N and D set to the single and dual guns
- add the 6.1'' tripples <_<
- touching the text

hoping there will be no more things to add :)

  • Re : IJN Range Chart

    01. 15. 2010 13:37

Challen76
Nice work so far TheFaller. I would recommend you make a new thread and put the
changes in the 2nd post so if/when it does get stickied and you need to make
updates, it won't change it's stickiness. I would also ask if you can make lines for the
smaller numbers, so ranges can be compared between gunsets that are far apart on
the chart.

Kudos to you for taking on this project!

  • Re : IJN Range Chart

    01. 15. 2010 13:17

Alex1884
Very well done!
Good job finishing it!

An already well known fact but now better shown: 12"L vs 14"N:
- range: same
- damage: 14"N wins
- spread: 14"N wins
- penetration: about same at max angle, 14"N wins at lower angles
- rushing capabilities: 14"N wins (since it's a 43deg gun compared to the 45 of the 12")
SUM: 14"N wins badly!

That's a clear hint to use them on Kongo, Asama and Ise CV as soon as your gunners
reach level
67!

  • Re : IJN Range Chart

    01. 15. 2010 11:22

Russianfleet
it very helpful chart tbh

but would be cool to see morethe rest of the guns :)

  • Re : IJN Range Chart

    01. 15. 2010 09:09

LordKelvin
I'm not going to sticky this just yet, mainly because it's incomplete. Since everything is
in the first post, every time he edits it it'll de-sticky the thread. Unless he wants to
put everything in a second post, it won't matter a whole lot.
1 2 3 4