ID
Password
FlashGuide
FlashGuide
HA Infomation

Kriegsmarine

  Index

  • Gneisenau vs Andrea Doria

    02. 18. 2012 22:29


LiquidQuartz
Which has more range? Which is funner to play?

 

  • Re : Gneisenau vs Andrea Doria

    02. 19. 2012 00:30


EricIdle
Use the search function.

You also need to be more precise:

- "ordinary" Gneisenau or EBB Gneisenau (1943)?
If we are talking "ordinary" Gneisenau, that one has slightly more range than Andrea Doria, but only six guns compared to the AD's ten. Both can mount AA, but the Gneisenau's is better (KM40s overall). The Gnei is much faster than the AD. The Gnei 1943 can mount Bismarck guns (2nd set 14.96" L) that give it a pip more range than the normal Gneisenau.

- at-level crew?
At-level, I'd say the AD experience is rather painful - getting outranged and not having the speed to make up for that. The ship comes into its own when your crew is way past the Gnei levels, in the 80s. Then the AD is agile and plays like a UK BB, as a brawler.

  • Re : Gneisenau vs Andrea Doria

    02. 19. 2012 11:42


LiquidQuartz
sorry for being vague but yes its for the ordinary Gneisenau and I can use the Bisy guns.

  • Re : Gneisenau vs Andrea Doria

    02. 26. 2012 01:03


PUR3R4Z0R
I dont think the normal Gnei can use Bissy guns.

  • Re : Gneisenau vs Andrea Doria

    02. 26. 2012 04:19


phantom3553
Originally Posted by PUR3R4Z0R

I dont think the normal Gnei can use Bissy guns.


well it can mount D guns but i think it won't have much ammo on it

  • Re : Gneisenau vs Andrea Doria

    03. 02. 2012 10:38


V2CxBongRipz
Originally Posted by EricIdle

Use the search function.

You also need to be more precise:

- "ordinary" Gneisenau or EBB Gneisenau (1943)?
If we are talking "ordinary" Gneisenau, that one has slightly more range than Andrea Doria, but only six guns compared to the AD's ten. Both can mount AA, but the Gneisenau's is better (KM40s overall). The Gnei is much faster than the AD. The Gnei 1943 can mount Bismarck guns (2nd set 14.96" L) that give it a pip more range than the normal Gneisenau.

- at-level crew?
At-level, I'd say the AD experience is rather painful - getting outranged and not having the speed to make up for that. The ship comes into its own when your crew is way past the Gnei levels, in the 80s. Then the AD is agile and plays like a UK BB, as a brawler.


I like AD's AA battery more then the Gneisenau's. Dont underestimate the premium single AA guns.

  • Re : Gneisenau vs Andrea Doria

    04. 10. 2012 22:26


vadarrog

Originally Posted by V2CxBongRipz
Originally Posted by EricIdle

Use the search function.

You also need to be more precise:

- "ordinary" Gneisenau or EBB Gneisenau (1943)?
If we are talking "ordinary" Gneisenau, that one has slightly more range than Andrea Doria, but only six guns compared to the AD's ten. Both can mount AA, but the Gneisenau's is better (KM40s overall). The Gnei is much faster than the AD. The Gnei 1943 can mount Bismarck guns (2nd set 14.96" L) that give it a pip more range than the normal Gneisenau.

- at-level crew?
At-level, I'd say the AD experience is rather painful - getting outranged and not having the speed to make up for that. The ship comes into its own when your crew is way past the Gnei levels, in the 80s. Then the AD is agile and plays like a UK BB, as a brawler.


I like AD's AA battery more then the Gneisenau's. Dont underestimate the premium single AA guns.

I don't get why ppl dont like RM or ADs AA battery, its actually really good and can take out planes thought they are singles

  • Re : Gneisenau vs Andrea Doria

    04. 11. 2012 05:42


Sanitarium

I think what you need to know here is the fact that AD has more support slots (you can raise more sailors simultaneously) also the AD although it has not got the range of Gneis it is much better due to the size and because is more agile and fast than the Gneis.

Overall AD is much better than ordinary Gneis. Its a fun ship to play with and once you lvl up a bit you will be very happy with it.

  • Re : Gneisenau vs Andrea Doria

    04. 11. 2012 15:08


V2CxBongRipz

Originally Posted by Sanitarium

Overall AD is much better than ordinary Gneis. Its a fun ship to play with and once you lvl up a bit you will be very happy with it.

Define better. Gneisenau would take the 1v1 encounter considering equal skill and crew.

  • Re : Gneisenau vs Andrea Doria

    04. 11. 2012 23:24


Sanitarium

@V2

I would agree with you if the player is an experienced one and knows how to play KM (which mostly keep them out of your range) and yes on 1v1 game gnei will win 90% of the time due to the range the 11" provide.

In a GB though things change. You have so many higher bbs running around that means you will not be as lucky. Also the AD is more agile and receives less damage (due to hitbox) which means it is a bit more forgiving.

Both ships are fun to play with but i would choose the AD over the Gnei due to support slots firstly and size.

1