"If I am hosting a normal room, don't even bother joining because 99 times out of 100 I
will boot you."

Stack them all on alpha its funnier that way. I've had a couple games where no one on the
other side had scouts. Yeah they complain but its their own fault they didnt bring them
not mine.

"The only room where you can ban people at will is on Normal Rooms (no shared exp) and
stating in the title of the room what you will ban (for example - "No scoutless BBs")"

Thats retarded. You can ban someone from normal rooms for any reason you want. I can ban
you because I dont like you, I can ban you because of your setup, I can ban you for
balance, I can ban you for causing disruptions in the room, hell I can ban you cause I
dont like your username.

""I play QV without a scout and win. "

Your scoutless QV is on my do not cover list when I play CV. "

Am I on your list of Epicness as opposed to the do not cover? >.<

As for scoutless BBs, scoutless BB6s in HA are semi acceptable as the scouting is mainly
done by competent CVs anyway (That said, anyone who HAS a scout should equip it, not sub
in and presume the CVs will scout), in no other situation is a scoutless BB acceptable.

If I am hosting a normal room, don't even bother joining because 99 times out of 100 I
will boot you.

No-one in Jedi will play a scoutless BB (My wrath descends if they do), but hey, we are a
noob fleet who don't know how to take a harbour because we run away all the time.



"and stating in the title of the room what you will ban (for example - "No scoutless BBs")"

Sorry Nyer but it has never been the case you must state exactly what you are banning for
(I ban everything and everyone and have never had any problems)... Otherwise my BB1-5
would read "BB1-5 No Tards, No scoutless BBs, no idiotic setups, no shared XP leechers, no
flaming" which clearly doesn't fit... You must warn inside the room but you are under no
obligation to put it in the room title.

Luedecke... in a shared exp room such as GB2, you can't ban anyone doesn't matter the
setup they have on their ships or how you want the room to be played. You can check all
your hosting rights in the shipyard screen by pressing the rules tab.

The only room where you can ban people at will is on Normal Rooms (no shared exp) and
stating in the title of the room what you will ban (for example - "No scoutless BBs")

Unless those rules change, we all have to deal with it.

Yesterday I was hosting a single GB2. I don't like scoutless BBs, that's why I banned all
BB4-5 without scouts (with warning of cause). Afterwards ppl were complaining that I'm not
allowed to ban scoutless BBs, that it's against the rules etc. etc.

I really would like to hear an official statement of the Mods about which rights a host
have or not.


btw. the Iwoa I asked to leave my room argued that he don't own a rookie pilot...

CV4+ without fighters is pathetic. I laugh every time one gets sunk because he couldnt
defend himself. Or when the all Bomber cv4+ blames his team for the loss when he only had
100k attack bombing from the back of the map and did nothing to contribute to the team but
bomb stuff that simply repaired and was never sunk.

As for BBs without scouts... They should be allowed but hosts should have the option of
banning them from their rooms. There are very few situations where I am completely blind
in a game even when my CVs have no fighter or are overpowered. A well controlled scout is
worth more then a CV that only scouts with its fighters. I dont even have 120 scouts and I
manage quite well. Anyone with a 120 scout should NEVER be blind for an extended period of
time.

Unfortunately even with 2 scout pilots I cannot scout the entire map and often find myself
getting shot at from areas just outside my scouts site thanks to my teamates. Just forcing
BBs to have scouts means that the chances they will use them is higher. Even if they do
not use them atleast those lazy slobs wont be able to level other things in that slot.

"I play QV without a scout and win. "

Your scoutless QV is on my do not cover list when I play CV.

I play QV without a scout and win.

CVs without fighters: Meh, if they know what they're doing fine, but I'd take 4 FW CVs
over 4 BW CVs anyday.

BBs without scouts: Should be shot.

BB with scouts but do not use them: Should be shot.

A BB without scouts puts extra pressure on his teams BB/CVs making it less likely for his
team to win.

I'll do you a deal, remove shared XP so I'm not relying on people like that for a team win
and they can play as they like. Untill then there should be something that makes people
learn to set up a BB effectivley

let others play how they want...

because...

if BB have scout that not automaticaly mean that he use scout effectively...

if CV have fighter that not automaticaly mean that he use fighters effectively...

The best idea is to give some reward for scouting...

http://www.navyfield.com/board/view.asp?Num=179978&Sort=D08

Exp for scouting; Be it via any plane, or a ship.