Actually, the BC concept was a pre-WWI idea that failed. The ships were designed for scouting or to fight cruisers, using their speed to stay out of range while hitting with their own bigger guns. They failed because sooner or later they came into contact with battleships who had the same size guns plus armor, or other battle cruisers with the same size guns causing devestating damage. The naval rule of thumb is that a ship should carry armor that can typically defeat its own guns. This is why after Jutland, battle cruisers were no longer in production. The only ones that come to instant memory are the four Japanse Kongos (rebuilt into BBs between wars and were devestated by the USN) The two Repulses, and the Hood (I shouldn't have to lecture about the failures of the BC regarding Hood!).
During WWII, the only things close to battle cruisers built were the Scharnhorst and Alaska Classes. The german ships were built with much more effective armor. The sacrificed the guns (using 11") while keeping speed and protection. The USN didn't want to call the Alaskas battle cruisers but rather large cruisers. Their life was very short. They were used roughly one year in the war, then mothballed and scrapped in 1960. The USN recognized that the Alaskas were a failed concept, hence the exceptionally short life, shorter than any other USN capital ship.
Finally, the most modern of all battleships, the Iowa class, was capable of the same 32-37 knot speed of the Alaska class. Ship designers in the US were able to put heavy guns, armor AND speed all on one platform with more modern engine output. The Alaska class, Kongo, Renown and Hood were all the same speed or slower.
Thus, the BC is entirely failed, except for those of us that admire the way they look or image so to speak. I think that the real solution here is to make it so that all the BB1/BC1s can just stay in blitz. GB should start with BB2s. When the game was started, there were probably a lot less BB5s/6s out there so it was a little easier. As time goes on, it will get harder and harder.
|