Community - Forum - View old data

Categories :  

Marine Nationale

  Index

  • Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 09. 2010 08:21

Rengokuy
PLEASE READ FIRST

Hello. I am currently compliling a list of the flaws with MN ships.

If you have encounted anything in your playtime with france that, seems wrong, then please
list it here in as much detail as possible.

EXAMPLE OF WHAT TO SAY

13.4/45 cal Model 1912 - This gun has very wide dispersion issues, regardless of crew
level or gunnary ability of the crew.

EXAMPLE OF WHAT NOT TO SAY

France Sucks

So what, KM needs fixed first

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I thank you in advance for all those whom particupate. I will take the most relievent
topics and ten make it into one large post on the suggestion forum. I will keep my own
isses otu to see if the community comes up with the same thing, at least for now.

______________________________________________________________

Going through the Topics this is what I have so far.
At level (and even above level) Dispersion for BB2,3,4 guns is too great.
Ammo Bind issues on All Battleship some Cruisers
Lorraine and Pairs are painfully slow, Lyon Normandie sorta slow (any others?)
Fighters are Pratically inuseable, even for scouting.
Alsace lvl 105 gun set, not worth the lvl.





  Index

  • Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 17. 2010 18:51

levisthered
I know you guys have said that the dbs and torp planes are powerful. As far as the
dive bombers go I love them they are totally badass. But the torp planes are made
of tissue paper. Also the torps are very slow. It very rarely happens that my torp
bombers make it back alive and almost never if i get close enough to score hits. I
would like it if they could make the torp planes more rugged and survivable or make
the torps faster maybe even nerf their damage a little I drive an ijn cv and i would
say the french torps are 2/3rds the speed of the ijn. right now i wish i hadn't classed
a torp pilot. I would appriciate som work on them.

Flame on!!!

  • Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 17. 2010 11:48

straswa
Jaguar barely fits the lvl 12 5.1" 1924 guns, only one bind. You have to use the lvl 10
5.1" 1919 guns to get more binds.

Pluton needs something more to make it a better ship.

Edit: Another call to fix the MN fighter fuel.

  • Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 10. 2010 18:37

Rengokuy
SadisticOne
Sitting on your arse and saying "whats the point" certinally wont get anything done, you
are correct. Fortunatly I'm not you. New Nations, Submarines.....yeh, when you try stuff
actual gets done. You actually have to try first though.

Thans everyone else so far, I've updated the list once more.

  • Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 10. 2010 18:05

SadisticOne
"If you have encounted anything in your playtime with france that, seems wrong,
then please
list it here in as much detail as possible"

Whats the point? Nothing will be done anyway.

  • Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 10. 2010 17:28

jorn978
im sick of my super low displacement and no room for ammo. That is all thank you for your
time :P

  • Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 10. 2010 15:40

marko30001
tourville T slots only can hold like 2 salvos of HH for most of the slots 2 slots can have 3.

La Galissonniere is terrible cant hold enough ammo on the main guns its 2 levels
higher then the other line and has 1 less gun and 4 less binds and the speed is about
the same i think.

  • Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 10. 2010 09:40

Rengokuy
I've gone though and picked some things onto the list so far...please look make sure you
agree, otherwise keep posting. Thank you.


The Faller


If you're referring to this video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84w-2g1wsqk

that is by no means an accurate portrayal of a Lyon. For startes. Every shell hits the
Yamato, and it criticals. For a 4 gunned Lyon at range,, maybe 2 out of 16 shells will
hit your target (this included BB6's) I would suggest you play with a ship before juding
how stong it is.

  • Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 10. 2010 09:05

Rehor
I have been reasonably pleased with the damage output of the Richelieu even with a rather
average spread. Not sure how the numbers would compare to the other BB4's, but I have
been able to chop through BB5's far more easily than I originally expected.

Richelieu ammo space is low.

Scout (all plane?) shadows are screwy.

  • Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 10. 2010 04:08

Cola
fully agree with decool
+ better angles for bb12 at the t-slots
courbet and paris has a side angle of 90 degrees, lyon in the front 90 degrees on the back 120 ( i
think) - why dont make them all 120 degrees, like every bb12 in the other nations
and yes, we need some guns, we can combine with smaller aa
like ijn with the 4,7" duals and 6,1" trips
the alsace has 4 big and 8 small slots, so it would be cool, if we would have some guns, that can
be combines with the 3,5" duals

  • Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships

    04. 10. 2010 03:58

deCool
AA guns need to be looked over. For example 5.1 " Duals and Quads share not the
same Golden Angel. Same is true for 6.1".

The quad 5.1 are meant to be used with the Stras but it only holds 4 binds. Thats
too low.

Quad 13" guns get fewer Shells per Bind than Quad 13.4". Thats a litte weird at
least. Change it to the 13.4 Values and you might have solved the amo Problem on
the Stras.

Best Engine for Stras is a CA Engine? Somewhat weird.

The aft R-Slots of Richelieu are pretty useless, better make T-Slots out of them and
create a AA-Combination witch works with the small T-Slots. Group them so that 1
Gunner controls the small and the other controls the Big ones. Of you do so 1
Gunnerslot will fall away so give herr another Supportslot.

Thats so far all i recall what need to be looked over.

Edit: Another remark for the Strasbourg:

Beside that it need another Supportslot (same Problem as with Dunk back then) i
would like to see an increase of useable displacement. Being new to the Ship i cant
carry any amount of armor while holding a decent speed (27/36 isnt too fast for a
BB3). In a few levels i will loose this speed due to fat crew. Simplest solution would
be to make the Quads ligther maybe by a 1000 tons each.
1 2 3 4 5