Super Yammy is the best BB5, then maybe L2. I haven't played an alsace yet. Since the Super Yamato has 45 degree guns descent range already, best aa on a BB arguably, and best speed on a bb5.
If both BB5s had same player ability and same crew types not just as in both for speed or repair or vice versa, but both have all bases +11 etc. It would also have to have both crews around the same level or both at 120, and a 120 Super Yamato is very very very fun to play. I'm not picking SY cause I have one, I'm picking it based on the facts, +'s, and -'s. Through and through the SY outbeats the L2 in it all.
Also if you can't catch a ship, how are you going to kill it? SY max speed 42, Alsace 42, Monty 40, H44 39 (I think, it's not that great anyways and it's not up for arguement for being better so it doesn't matter.), then L2 is 39. If you rush a SY or monty, they can easily range you by running with 45 degree angle guns, and of course they go faster than the L2 at max speed already. Therefore that's a clear loss the L2 has again.
The L2 is a really good ship not saying it's a bad bb5 like the H44. It also is very good against BB6s, but against other BB5s its 2nd or 3rd, not first.
|