Community - Forum - View old data

Categories :  

Kriegsmarine

  Index

  • Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    10. 31. 2007 06:47

Obst
This thread is to rework the evaluation on the Hipper/Deutschland lines of ships.

Due to the ONF changes this has become necessary.

The real content will be posted below, so that this thread does not get de-stickied upon
being modified by me.
  Index

  • Re : Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    09. 23. 2008 22:04

yim1990
Skillful player go PS.
New player go Admiral Hipper.
PS need a precise micro to control the 11".
New player should better go Admiral Hipper,
although 8" are scattered and not easily to handle,
compare with 11" which is much better.

  • Re : Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    09. 23. 2008 15:58

whiteblur
Now Pepek the only thing i question on your experiance is, if you quit before you hit the
ship lanes bread winner O project can you truely make a determination about that ship lane?

after all placing your opinion on one of many ships in the tree is like picking a bad
apple off the ground and using it to explain all the apples in the tree must be bad too.

  • Re : Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    09. 23. 2008 13:47

Pepek
more or less correct,

yes, with the dland you start to learn handling long reload times and bb ranged weapons at
ca stage , while the hipp and the pe allow you to keep the play style of cl/ca like ships
for longer.

never the less you will have to keep in mind how the line continues and ask yourself what
ships you want to play after the cas.
I went dland ppro and had then to buy a linereset to go scharn as i didnt like the pproII.
So, if you have the bucks to change the line then the dland is a good trainer in my
opinion, but considering that you also can buy a moltke to train the playstyle sparing 15
bucks compared the treereset it may be better to go hippe if you want to play the bissy line.

regards

  • Re : Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    09. 23. 2008 11:04

whiteblur
So in all actuality the primary difference is that you keep a slightly faster firing ship
longer, making it more Blitz friendly if you take the Hipper lane.

And if you Take the Deutschland lane you have a more suitable training platform for
your future in the battleship styled conflicts from the guns and the range, so in a
sense, someone who wants to try a steep battleship learning curve should go for
the Pocket Battleship route I.E. Deutschland?

  • Re : Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    09. 21. 2008 15:16

Pepek
/signed for the most part

my problem with this evaluation is the point of view you take dear obst.

you evaluate the ships in a way usefull in the old days, the good old earn you expy rooms
where range made a difference even at cl stage.
mpro was a might and the PE a killer then.
they are gone now and will never come back and therfore youll need to take a different
angle for this.

my opinion about the lines is:
you want to play gb go dland, you get range and aa that can make a difference there.
planning to stay longer in blitz, get hipper then PE as you get more possible setups with
better guns, faster reload/ closer spread at comperable lvl, for the battle styles there.

i like flavor , therfore i hated the ppro ships of the later stages, thou dland was great
fun as i went the line with the second bo and higher lvl gunners, the rest are ugly like
a floating brick and i swaped my bb bo back to the bissy line after my first went cv.

yes there is always a moltke or the doria to buy and get the edge in both game types over
the non prem ships , but not all ppl buy them and honestly said id bet on a pe in a 1on1
with a moltke as its faster, ship and gun vise, and a smaller target.

regards

  • Re : Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    08. 19. 2008 06:10

Alexpanter
Nice job!

I finaly decided to go for the hipper, because my gunners are lvl 44 and my BO is lvl
46...



  • Re : Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    08. 18. 2008 11:29

Hammer8
Dont ask me 0_0

  • Re : Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    08. 18. 2008 00:16

jonnaf
admiral ofcourse!

  • Re : Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    08. 08. 2008 17:48

xTripWirex
Thanks I am just about to get rid of my m project this helped my decision a lot

  • Re : Deutschland or Admiral Hipper? (v2)

    08. 07. 2008 23:41

greyheart
how about getting a nice bb? what should I prefer?
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next Last