Categories :

Marine Nationale

Please list any greievence you have with your ships
04. 09. 2010 08:21

Rengokuy	PLEASE READ FIRST Hello. I am currently compliling a list of the flaws with MN ships. If you have encounted anything in your playtime with france that, seems wrong, then please list it here in as much detail as possible. EXAMPLE OF WHAT TO SAY 13.4/45 cal Model 1912 - This gun has very wide dispersion issues, regardless of crew level or gunnary ability of the crew. EXAMPLE OF WHAT NOT TO SAY France Sucks So what, KM needs fixed first ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I thank you in advance for all those whom particupate. I will take the most relievent topics and ten make it into one large post on the suggestion forum. I will keep my own isses otu to see if the community comes up with the same thing, at least for now. ______________________________________________________________ Going through the Topics this is what I have so far. At level (and even above level) Dispersion for BB2,3,4 guns is too great. Ammo Bind issues on All Battleship some Cruisers Lorraine and Pairs are painfully slow, Lyon Normandie sorta slow (any others?) Fighters are Pratically inuseable, even for scouting. Alsace lvl 105 gun set, not worth the lvl.

Rengokuy

PLEASE READ FIRST

Hello. I am currently compliling a list of the flaws with MN ships.

If you have encounted anything in your playtime with france that, seems wrong, then please
list it here in as much detail as possible.

EXAMPLE OF WHAT TO SAY

13.4/45 cal Model 1912 - This gun has very wide dispersion issues, regardless of crew
level or gunnary ability of the crew.

EXAMPLE OF WHAT NOT TO SAY

France Sucks

So what, KM needs fixed first

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I thank you in advance for all those whom particupate. I will take the most relievent
topics and ten make it into one large post on the suggestion forum. I will keep my own
isses otu to see if the community comes up with the same thing, at least for now.

______________________________________________________________

Going through the Topics this is what I have so far.
At level (and even above level) Dispersion for BB2,3,4 guns is too great.
Ammo Bind issues on All Battleship some Cruisers
Lorraine and Pairs are painfully slow, Lyon Normandie sorta slow (any others?)
Fighters are Pratically inuseable, even for scouting.
Alsace lvl 105 gun set, not worth the lvl.

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships
05. 16. 2010 08:59

vcadoda	bb23s are incredibly broken at high lvls. Yes they are limited by at lvl crews. But with high OH these are incredibly hard to hit with their small hit boxes especially for other low lvl bbs.

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships
05. 16. 2010 02:49

NIborGER	Strass can be really fast with CA II engine. You can go 27/45 knots but to reach the speedcap you need better engies then for H44. Thats the issue. It's just incredible hard to reach maximum speed. So most StrassBourgs just run around 27/37 with atlvl crew.

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships
05. 15. 2010 21:37

masterjeddi	The strassbourg needs to be buff. especially for the speed. It should be like South Dakota's speed.

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships
04. 29. 2010 07:15

Elliot2lazy	My main grievences arnt until the alsace, which you can only shoot 35 shots in one game with your main guns. Speed is not an issue with the small french bb2 and 2.5 when you can in Lyon can one shot all the bb5s. Ive tested it myself. The only issue i have with stras bourge is it has small shells so therefore means its a lot harder to hit them dead on. Although range and speed are good on this ship too. Richelieu has too little range and too bulky of a ship if it has no range. As well with the strasbourg these guns need to get bigger even if it was just to 16" then it would give people more breathing room on hitting people. Maybe you wingmann you can't enter a battle without the front gun, but you can take off one of the back guns on the Lyon, ive seen many players do it.

Elliot2lazy

My main grievences arnt until the alsace, which you can only shoot 35 shots in one
game with your main guns.

Speed is not an issue with the small french bb2 and 2.5 when you can in Lyon can
one shot all the bb5s. Ive tested it myself.

The only issue i have with stras bourge is it has small shells so therefore means its a
lot harder to hit them dead on. Although range and speed are good on this ship too.

Richelieu has too little range and too bulky of a ship if it has no range. As well with
the strasbourg these guns need to get bigger even if it was just to 16" then it
would give people more breathing room on hitting people.

Maybe you wingmann you can't enter a battle without the front gun, but you can
take off one of the back guns on the Lyon, ive seen many players do it.

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships
04. 28. 2010 09:02

BillySilver	Yes, MN is OP. Slow but hardest target as a low lv BBs for DBs or TBs. What more dispersed shells but twice of triple # shells, in addition not too bad dam/shell. Small and low hitbox for non ebve BBs of other nations. BB5 well, Alsace's horrible, bigger yet, and still slow XD. My fav DBing target. Exceptional AA rel ? With it's sux dam/shell, a good DB driver take it a considerable challenge. Not an extreme one.

BillySilver

Yes, MN is OP. Slow but hardest target as a low lv BBs for DBs or TBs. What more
dispersed shells but twice of triple # shells, in addition not too bad dam/shell. Small and
low hitbox for non ebve BBs of other nations. BB5 well, Alsace's horrible, bigger yet, and
still slow XD. My fav DBing target. Exceptional AA rel ? With it's sux dam/shell, a good DB
driver take it a considerable challenge. Not an extreme one.

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships
04. 28. 2010 08:06

FatStrat	"I have a problem that the french doesn't have actual AA guns. I didnt know this and now have two useless machine gunners in my t slots. " Well sadly we have another instance of user error. there are guides and a post by TNF if i'm not mistaken... +1 for reading

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships
04. 28. 2010 00:46

deCool	@Rage_Kaj: look at the stickied Thread #2 on this page. It큦 sitting there since the day MN came out. BTW it`s always a good idea to read the guides when you start up a new Nation ;)

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships
04. 27. 2010 19:26

Rage_Kaj	I have a problem that the french doesn't have actual AA guns. I didnt know this and now have two useless machine gunners in my t slots.

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships
04. 26. 2010 12:02

TheFaller	wow, a Lyon just managed to put my ship on yellow, and basicly only half of his shells did damage..... if there's any ship in need of buffed spread, lyon isnt one of them, dmg compensates it. (my ship was a 900SD nelson)

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships
04. 26. 2010 11:12

Viper01	Richilieu not enough range...most ships have too little ammo.

1 2 3 4 5

Categories : Game News & Updates General Discussion Off-Topic Test Server Discussion Tip and Tactics Technical Support Suggestions Trade and Bater U.S Navy Royal Navy Imperial Japanese Navy Kriegsmarine Marine Nationale Soviet Navy

Marine Nationale

Please list any greievence you have with your ships 04. 09. 2010 08:21

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships 05. 16. 2010 08:59

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships 05. 16. 2010 02:49

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships 05. 15. 2010 21:37

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships 04. 29. 2010 07:15

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships 04. 28. 2010 09:02

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships 04. 28. 2010 08:06

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships 04. 28. 2010 00:46

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships 04. 27. 2010 19:26

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships 04. 26. 2010 12:02

Re : Please list any greievence you have with your ships 04. 26. 2010 11:12