Well it's good that you're patriotic and value your uncle's experiences. Absolutely awesome.
But don't let that blind you.
Invincible - launched 1980. 28 knots, 7000 nm range, 22 aircraft Nimitz - launched 1975. 33 knots, unlimited range, 90 aircraft
Winner... Nimitz. Clearly.
But a CV is also limited by its escort ships. So this comes down to Type 45 vs Arleigh Burke. The Type 45 wins in endurance, having a 7000 nm range to match the CV it protects, while the AB's have a crappy 4400 nm range and depend greatly on a worldwide network of bases. But the Type 45 is a specialist. it can be fitted for EITHER antiaircraft with a 48 cel surface to air battery, OR Land/Sea attack with 8 Harpoons and the older model BGM 109 Tomahawks. The Arleigh Burke instead features a Mk41 multicel launch system (96 missiles) capable of firing any or all surface to air, surface to surface, and ASW ordnance, typically carrying a mix of all of them.
The Arleigh Burkes also handle ASW duties, which are carried out by the Royal Navy using Type 23 Frigates instead (which is a smaller ship, but equipped for ASW, anti-ship, and anti-aircraft duties... basically it can do anything except attack a land based target). Thus the US Navy uses 1 ship for multiple roles while the Royal Navy uses several more specialized frigates and destroyers.
Winnner... Arleigh Burke.
I would rate one post WW2 Royal Navy vessel as superior to US Navy ships, though. The Leander class frigate. They're all gone now, but for 30 years, these ships were the definitive multi-role missile platform. Converted to use the Exocet platform in the 70's and the Seawolf platform in the 80's, it was a solid support ship for it's entire career. Phased out over the last 20 years, only one remains in service, HMS Andromeda, sold to India as a training vessel in 1995 and renamed INS Krishna.
|