PST Time 00:00:00GMT-8
Local Server Time 00:00:00GMT+8
ID
Password
FlashGuide
FlashGuide
HA Infomation

Suggestions
Forum Quick Menu

  Index

  • Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 04:07

Recommend : 6

Ukelele
Last week there was an attack on a harbour and shortly after starting the HA, the fleetleader of the attacking fleet left the game leaving their fleetmates and the defender fleet stuck on the HA without chance to cancell it. I suggest to add an auto cancel function where if attackers fails to create a room in 10/15 minutes the HA ends. I consider a total lack of respect and a big time lost to leave fleetmates and defending fleet on a HA where the attacking fleet has ended to attack due to the lack of the fleet leader.

Regards
Uke (lele)


*Removed the parts that singled out players and fleets - Ny*

 

  • Re : Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 04:36


osmori
good suggestion, just have to check that the HA doesn't cancel itself due to those pesky NF bugs. +1

*Removed comment regarding a single player - Ny*

  • Re : Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 04:43


quietcos
Don't see the point of cancelling HA - just cancel the player... problem solved.

  • Re : Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 05:38


nyerkovic
This is an interesting suggestion, however, I removed the parts that singled out fleets and players so this doesn't turn into a flame and blame post. Let's concentrate on the suggestion.

  • Re : Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 06:09


Thebarrel
i remember one ha some months ago where the attacking fleet was litterally waiting an hour before opening any tiles..... +1

  • Re : Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 06:55


PepeLeBou
Nice suggestion.
+1.

  • Re : Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 09:27


ljsevern
Its been suggested for a long time. It should auto cancel if:-

a) A tile has not been taken in 45 minutes

b) No rooms have been made in 10 minutes AND there are no ongoing rooms

c) Should cancel if the attack doesn't have access to the harbour tile by 1 hour 30.

  • Re : Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 12:53


Ukelele
Originally Posted by ljsevern

Its been suggested for a long time. It should auto cancel if:-

a) A tile has not been taken in 45 minutes

b) No rooms have been made in 10 minutes AND there are no ongoing rooms

c) Should cancel if the attack doesn't have access to the harbour tile by 1 hour 30.


Except from b) I do not agree with the other statements because a small fleet must have the chance to practice HA no matter if they win a tile or not in 45 minutes and even if they have not reached the harbour tile in 1:30. I know it's a boring sometimes for the defenders to battle against small fleets that have no chance whatsoever to reach the harbour, but we must try to let small fleets have the chance to play HA and it's even useful for deffenders fleet to train their new members. This suggestion was based on a recent HA where the attacker fleetleader left the game shortly after start, leaving their fleetmembers on her own without chance to cancel the attack.

Regards
Uke (lele)

  • Re : Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 14:28


aide4
problem with A


What about harbor tiles? they commonly run more then 45 mins.

  • Re : Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 14:37


Happymeal2
Originally Posted by aide4

problem with A


What about harbor tiles? they commonly run more then 45 mins.

Hes suggesting all 3 are implemented on top of each other. Read B and C.

  • Re : Auto cancel HA

    03. 02. 2012 14:51


aide4
didn't read it like that

read it as if

if any of the three conditions are met the harbor assault will be cancelled.

1 2