No I think in this case it does.  I've been following his suggestions  for the past few weeks and at the same time seen him in game.  It's premature.  Once someone has gone through at least a nation's entire line I can accept it but in this case, the max level is around 50.  That's not enough to formulate anything.  I'm trying to be very understanding in this case but if you go through his other suggestion you will see it is mainly based on ignorance due to lack of experience.

I understand lower level players might want certain armaments/abilities but at the same time they need to be earned.  In this case they haven't even bothered to level and are asking for changes.  They haven't seen the full capabilities of the sailors not to mention the armaments and are talking about changes.  Play all the ships, try all the guns, maximize the ability of those sailors and then make suggestions based on TOTAL experience not the bits and pieces from the early stages.

I should and will soften my tone.

I would like to see ships and armaments that are usable for at level or at least near at level sailors. 
My only concern with an inexperienced player is that if they were using - for example - a 12aaw 7 reload sailor complaining about the performance of aa, well it's fairly ignorant.

I have made the mistake of accusing Chaosticket of being inexperienced due to what I have seen in-game, the stats of stuff he might sell on the trade board etc.  From there I have treated  all his suggestions as "buff my ship."  But in my defense I think we all perceive a lot of things the first time around as being unfair or not adequate.  When we redo things we know what stats are important, how to play the ship, what the best armaments are etc etc.  Often things don't feel as bad the second time around and that's my point.

I think we all have differing opinions on this but when I didn't like the way a certain ship was, we just used another one OR armed that ship in a way that it was most effective.  I've always looked at it as - this is the way "Ship A" was designed.  If I can make it work fine ~ if not then I will use something else.  I've never been compelled to have a ship changed to suit my needs.   I also felt that if I could make a cumbersome ship really effective then it would make me special. So when possible I've tried to make the best of a "difficult" ship. There really are so many ships available for use ~ does each one need to be discussed here?

So what you going to say for UK (not that poms poms) and RM aa? Also I am still waiting for your answer to a 1 vs 1 challenge. You ignored me and then go afk when i ask you for 1 vs 1 and personally chaos, you chould play a line and not having all other nation line like "someone" else and complain about the exp and give suggestion for changes. 

@Mako089  
he said km line is bad until bb4 and i simply pop in saying "bismarck is good too".