ID
Password
FlashGuide
FlashGuide
HA Infomation

Suggestions

  Index

  • Joke Weapon: United States 5/54mm guns need reasonable AA shells

    03. 10. 2014 11:38

Recommend : 0

Chaosticket

the United States navy 5"/54 cal Mark 16 dual purpose guns are bugged/nerfed to do only 45 damage using AA shells. Combined with its rate of fire its about 25% at effective as the 5/38 dual purpose gun.

Checking other nations' and even other USN 5inch guns, this damage is far too low with the next weakest gun doing 79damage.

The damage should be between 80 and 100 per shell.

===================================

Ive heard an argument that its not designed for anti-aircraft gun. Thats wrong as its a DUAL PURPOSE Gun, like other high-angle guns. Specifically it was made for the Montana battleship and used on the Midway carrier. Some of the dual-purpose guns are slow-reloading but theyre also stronger than faster-firing weapons.

 

  • Re : Joke Weapon: United States 5/54mm guns need reasonable AA shells

    03. 25. 2014 04:26


phantom3553

Originally Posted by babyheart

 

he said km line is bad until bb4 and i simply pop in saying "bismarck is good too".



lol @ this... did he even played 1? or just simply assuming, the PPro II is a nice bb1, with a good aa placement, gnessy a good bb2 its a speeder, between bissy and oproII, I find fun playing bissy the best bb3 if you played it right

  • Re : Joke Weapon: United States 5/54mm guns need reasonable AA shells

    03. 25. 2014 12:16


Chaosticket

What does an out-of-context statement about battleships have to do with the United States Navy 5/54mm guns?

Stay-on-topic.

  • Re : Joke Weapon: United States 5/54mm guns need reasonable AA shells

    03. 25. 2014 14:45


EricIdle

Originally Posted by Chaosticket

What does an out-of-context statement about battleships have to do with the United States Navy 5/54mm guns?

Stay-on-topic.

And those guns are not "5/54mm", they are 5 in/54 calibres barrel length.

Get your facts right.

  • Re : Joke Weapon: United States 5/54mm guns need reasonable AA shells

    03. 25. 2014 16:44


mako089

This post is not on topic so I apologize ahead of time.

It's not necessarily focused on this topic either but as I said before - you've dabbled in the lower tier ships of several nations.  It doesn't seem like you have finished or even leveled to a mid tier BB so I must conclude that your crew still hasn't reached its potential either.  Without that experience it's premature for you to make as many suggestions as you have.

Originally Posted by Chaosticket

Forums are better for getting trolls then getting people to agree to an idea unless it specifically helps them. Anyone who doesnt use the Atlanta class wont care for any changes.

There is some irony in that statement.  I think most of the people who have been replying to you have played those ships and played them the way they were meant to be played.  We don't care about your changes to the Atlanta for example because we changed our methods to make the ship useable.  You're asking for a ship(s) to be changed to fit the way you want to play it.  That was evident with the RM DD suggestion.  You wanted to plow into people with duals when clearly the more powerful, rapid firing, and ranging singles were the better choice.  Instead of the following my advice you insisted on having the ship changed to suit you.

Some weapons/ships/arcs/nations aren't as good as others.  Sometimes we are able to adapt to play them, sometime we can't.  But that's what makes each of those different and unique.  For almost a decade people have dealt with the pluses and minuses of each ship and worked with it.  Don't change the ship to suit you, change yourself to suit the ship.  There are 7(+1) nations.  Also if you can't adapt to the playstyle of a certain ship then skip it.  In the nation specific sections you will sometimes see people ask about a ship - how it plays or describe the way they like to play and ask for the appropriate nation/line to try.  They read the advice and choose accordingly.  That's what you need to do.  Tell us how you like to play and/or what your limitations are and perhaps we will be able to suggest the nation best suited to you.  From there actually go beyond your current level 50.  Until you have more experience, people here will just think you are "Quenirlanding."

 

  • Re : Joke Weapon: United States 5/54mm guns need reasonable AA shells

    03. 25. 2014 17:05


soulseeker4

Originally Posted by mako089

"Quenirlanding."



"Mobeusing or rather sailoring" 

  • Re : Joke Weapon: United States 5/54mm guns need reasonable AA shells

    03. 26. 2014 00:14


EricIdle

Originally Posted by mako089
people here will just think you are "Quenirlanding."

Spot on.

1 2 3