|
|
-
Give exp...
03. 21. 2012 21:35
 Recommend : 8
SiriusA
|
For TKing 8/9/10/11/12 planes launched on 1 pilot.
Or TKing the CV that launched them.
Discuss.
|
-
Re : Give exp...
04. 05. 2012 19:34
jubdub1
|
Originally Posted by Bart133
CVs who launch 10 planes on one pilot deserve to have them TKed, and TKing them is not hurting the team (because they are not contributing).
If you launch 10 planes on one pilot, being screwed with frustration isn't enough. You need to get red experience in a shared exp room. Why? Because if you launch 10 planes on a pilot, you are an idiot. That's all.
It's no harder to tell that one pilot has more than 6 planes than it is to tell that a plane is an enemy. Let people know that they only get exp if there are 7+ planes on the pilot and penalize them for TKing groups of less than 7, and they'll get the idea.
Your ridiculous logic is making my head hurt. No matter how many ways we can refute the same logic over and over, you just keep spouting the same crap all day. If I were a CV and I saw my 7 stacked planes get shot down by a friendly, I wouldn't think, "Oh! He's doing it to show me that I should spread out my planes across multiple pilots!" No. I would get royally pissed off at that AA'er, and then probably TK him back with PHH 'cause he's being a dick. Any contribution there? No. It hurts the team more than it helps. People have different playing styles. If they want to stack planes, that's their choice. You can't penalize someone for how they play the game. And if the CV is new to the game, he probably won't have 4 classed fighter pilots and 3 bombers. He'll probably have one or two of each. Shooting down someone who is new won't help them. It will turn away the new ones, and if it was ever implemented I would leave too. Bottom line is, you're just flaming and blaming the CVs because you're not good enough of a BB player to be able to fight even though the CVs might have been doing a bad job.
|
-
Re : Give exp...
04. 05. 2012 20:13
Bart133
|
Originally Posted by jubdub1
Your ridiculous logic is making my head hurt. No matter how many ways we can refute the same logic over and over, you just keep spouting the same crap all day. If I were a CV and I saw my 7 stacked planes get shot down by a friendly, I wouldn't think, "Oh! He's doing it to show me that I should spread out my planes across multiple pilots!" No. I would get royally pissed off at that AA'er, and then probably TK him back with PHH 'cause he's being a dick. Any contribution there? No. It hurts the team more than it helps. People have different playing styles. If they want to stack planes, that's their choice. You can't penalize someone for how they play the game. And if the CV is new to the game, he probably won't have 4 classed fighter pilots and 3 bombers. He'll probably have one or two of each. Shooting down someone who is new won't help them. It will turn away the new ones, and if it was ever implemented I would leave too. Bottom line is, you're just flaming and blaming the CVs because you're not good enough of a BB player to be able to fight even though the CVs might have been doing a bad job.
Noob AAers that TK all friendly planes they see hoping for extra exp are the same noob AAers whose idea of AAing is to put their guns at the golden angle and jam the spacebar. Hmm, I wonder if there's a way to avoid getting AAed by golden angle spacebar-jamming. Oh hey! Extra bonus to this idea, it makes CVs not leave their planes at default height.
If a CV high enough level to know better is putting all his planes on one pilot, he's dumb and leeching, and should be penalized in the same way as an H39 driver whose chosen way of playing the game is to put one 11" D single on, use HHE and bulkhead whore.
If a CV is new to the game and only has three pilots, he should be using a CA or AA ship to level his other pilots, and someone should tell him that. Like the tutorials built in to the game.
As if getting your T1s eaten by swarms of Moltkes and US AAW and UFOs isn't already enough to turn away new CV players.
I can play BB with leeching CVs using three pilots on a Taiho on my team. Do I want to? No. It's much more fun when the only person at fault for problems in my games is me, and likewise when I don't have to depend on a bunch of nose pickers who decide how well I'm going to do.
I'm much less likely to win or get high attack when CVs on my team are playing the game in such a wrong way. Just as when I'm in a CV (or BB or something else) I don't like having BB teammates who can't play.
Somehow I think you're in an odd place to call me a bad player.
CVs who launch 8/9/10/11/12 planes on one pilot are not contributing to the team.
|
-
Re : Give exp...
04. 05. 2012 20:24
jubdub1
|
Originally Posted by Bart133
CVs who launch 8/9/10/11/12 planes on one pilot are not contributing to the team.
Have you ever considered the fact that CVs who stack planes and launch them might actually be able to USE the planes? Or do you assume that whoever stacks planes automatically gets shot down? If a CV can bomb a target, escort a bomber group, or protect BBs from enemy bombers, then they did in fact contribute. Doesn't matter how they do it, as long as they do. There will always be failed bombing runs, no matter how the planes are launched. Implementing this won't help at all. Noob CVs will still contribute as much as they would have if they stacked their planes and got shot down on the way.
|
-
Re : Give exp...
04. 05. 2012 22:43
Bart133
|
CVs who launch 8/9/10/11/12 planes on one pilot are not contributing to the team.
I'm starting to be a broken record.
|
-
Re : Give exp...
04. 06. 2012 10:04
jubdub1
|
Originally Posted by Bart133
CVs who launch 8/9/10/11/12 planes on one pilot are not contributing to the team.
I'm starting to be a broken record.
Okay, let me ask you this: If a CV launches 8/9/10/11/12 planes and successfully sinks the enemy De Grasse, was he not contributing?
|
-
Re : Give exp...
04. 06. 2012 15:44
Iced8383
|
Originally Posted by jubdub1
Originally Posted by Bart133
CVs who launch 8/9/10/11/12 planes on one pilot are not contributing to the team.
I'm starting to be a broken record.
Okay, let me ask you this: If a CV launches 8/9/10/11/12 planes and successfully sinks the enemy De Grasse, was he not contributing?
No. He's not going to sink the De Grasse. He's going to auto bomb a CL and miss.
|
-
Re : Give exp...
04. 06. 2012 19:33
MaskdBandit
|
Tired of everyone beating the dead cliche that is "no noobs just bomb CLs/Nevadas/crap.
Tired of this thread because it's just bart ranting about how he'd like to have fun jerking around CV players who just don't know how to play. No one loads up a pilot with 7+ because it's so much easier or they're lazy, it's cuz they don't know what they're doing. F#($ing with them isn't going to change that fact.
Regardless of how inefficient it is to load 7+planes on one pilot, that's all that it is. Inefficient. You shooting down their planes, that's "not contributing" and is in fact only hindering your team at that point. You're not even making the best out of a bad situation, you're just being a d*&$ teammate.
SDE is never going to add anything to this game that promotes punishing noob players, you raving fool, for many good reasons.
|
-
Re : Give exp...
04. 06. 2012 20:15
SiriusA
|
I'll keep this short and simple.
Obviously this will never be implemented (Or better or for worse...)
Obviously putting a limit on how many planes you can put on 1 pilot is the best solution.
Obvious Troll isn't Obvious.
Obviously,defending putting all those planes on 1 pilot is retarded.
|
-
Re : Give exp...
04. 06. 2012 21:14
jubdub1
|
Originally Posted by Iced8383
No. He's not going to sink the De Grasse. He's going to auto bomb a CL and miss.
Oh, you can predict exactly what noob CV players are going to do, can you? You can just tell that a Zuikaku with his other bombers out who loads up 8 is just going to auto-bomb an Atlanta and miss, experienced though he is? I'll make sure to contact you so you can predict the outcome of a battle for me.
|
-
Re : Give exp...
04. 06. 2012 21:45
ChicagoBears
|
I don't load all of my planes on one pilot but IMO people who TK planes intentionally should be banned just like if you sunk a team mate intentionally. This is because:
1. It hurts your team by giving the enemy CV's a chance to bomb ships, BB's to scout and sink ships, and also the CV will have to load another set of planes and has one less wave of fighters.
2. It can cause the CV to lose exp AND credits at the same time
3. It's even worse when you're in an AAW ship and you TK 11 PLANES TO GET ONE FRIGGEN SCOUT
So, if anything killing 9+ planes should=exp loss not gain because then people would TK intentionally just to get exp and if your team TKed all 3 CVs on your side then, well your team will lose 99.99% of the time.
|
|
|
