Roger

Ok, I have redone the sign up for with the added information regading alliuiance sign ups, I have also added the alliance information in the Rules under section 2.2

Please bare in mind you are applying to join the league with this sign up and you will be emailed with a confirmation after the sign ups close.

Regards,
vk222u.

I just started to like rules... but now we have the new ones again :)

And cant say that it is going to make the league better.

 

What the logic that led to the new rules?) I have some guesses, but i'd like to know your opinion VK :) 

Great decision VK! Now all fleets will have 8 BB 4 CV and 3 SS2 (because it's the strongest setup here). And how will games appear? 3 SS is enough to give no chances for playing ss, but it's unreal to attack using SS2. 8 BB is enough to keep line still and safe. 4 CV is enough to defense from bombers. Congratulations, we have another HA, but without smokes. Remove SS2 as support and restriction for count SS3 or remove new rules at all! It doesnt work when we have enough ships for everything and even don't need to choose!

sorry forgot to copy the BB, Cv & SS changes over from my draft :D.

 

The choice is something I was looking at over the last few weeks but couldn't get it right until I looked at it again this evening.

 

The Battleships are now limited back to 7.

The Aircraft Carriers reduced to 5.

Submarines stay at 4 maximum(2 ss3 max)

 

this would allow either a CV/BB line up without subs 7/5 or include submarines and take away Battleships and CVs, this opens up the door for better tactics with ship tiers that are already quite balanced.

 

In hand with same ship restrictions and nation restriction this should help keep it balanced.

 

Remember you can not have two submarines of the same nation which also stops any op lineup.

 

sorry for the late update, I had to leave and go out which I was not planning on doing.

 

Regards,
vk

 

1. Reduce the number of ships to 20! Like it was before (10 capital and 10 support).

2. SS2 its capital ships or support?

3. You must stop changing rules every day!  

As Adorius has posted above, no team will choose SS3 because 3 SS2 can keep defense from any count of SS3. Why don't forbid SS2 as support and let fleets choose 12 bb-cv-ss on their own? 

It would be great if we have choice between three classes with high limits.(8-9bb, 5-6cv, 2-3ss like it was in the summer) .

 

Or give 10 capital ships back  if you don't agree that we should give green light for attacking SS.   

@Sharn,

I have spent months working on this and looking at it every day so I don't think you get what I am trying to do. I spend a lot of time calculating and testing things so I don't just make a change to see if it will work.

I understand your fustration but we are still in sign up phase so slight changes can be made to better fit the fleets that have signed up. So far all have stated they have over 100 member so 22 is not a problem.

 

1a. it will stay at 22 (12 Capital and 10 support)

2a. SS are now capital for every class

3a. I don't change them every day, I have made in total 4 changes since I made this post, if you count fixing grammer and clearing things up maybe more, but they are not counted as rule changes.

"2a. SS are now capital for every class"

Ok sorry, I just didnt noticed it :) Then everything is OK :)