Quite a bold statment, unless ppl are saying no to a certian kind of person, meaning age,sex, or color of skin, your comment holds absolutly no water, you statment can be used in a lot of battle modes that also have this function, please refrain from using color race themes to prove your unvalid point

You stated in your original post that NavyFIELD is not the same as real life but you then you state that we must follow real life modern day protocols, You contradicted your very own statement thus eliminating 2 statements that you have brought in your defence to remove the no torp option.

You also state tha Modern day protocols mean staying near carriers for protection which is entirely untrue no matter what your defence is for "Modern day",  In 2013 modern day, there are rarely any battleships around since the carrier is much more effective than any battleship and all ships haves sonar. In WWII the only ships with sonar were Figates and Destoryers which were the designated submarine hunters and thus also eliminated your last statement that bbs should remain near vessels with sonar. Sonar does not work on BBs and there is a blind spot on carriers when a sonar is equipped.

You also state that surface ships get a preference over submarines which is untrue, if anything submarines get a preference, and with that preference they are excluded from World At War. Submarines are overpower in Great Battles and can not be killed as easily as one may think. No one wants an uncapped submarine sailing twoards them in any situation. 

 

Capital* I normally do not correct people on grammar and spelling but you are using higher vocabularly and should use it correctly. Submarines may not have an unlimited of oxygen but they still remain cappless in terms of speed and are able to reach the bb lines rather quick, even in a Great Battle room they are able to reach the bb line. 

I do not support the option of removing the No Torp option but im also not saying we should allow submarines to roam in every WaW battleroom. Fromage has made a very good statment say that submarines should be fixed, until that day arrives keep the settings the way they currently exist.

 

Actually, sonar was never equipped on BBs and only twice in history on a CV, on the sister ships Shokaku and Zuikaku.  However, the sonar was only usable when at very low speed.  Thus my argument that sonar be removed from CVs, since there is no basis in any reality, in any dimensional phase, for sonar to be placed on the world's loudest warship class.  They will only hear themselves. 

 

If this game must place sonar on a CV, it should only be on those two and it should only work at 3 kts or less.  If you want to argue with me, first know that I am a Sonar Technician in the United States Navy, next know that I am a huge naval history buff, and finally know that I never use websites for information because I can rely on my collection of over 300 reference books in my personal library.

 

 

Source for sonar on CVs:

Preston, Antony.  Aircraft Carriers.  Galahad Books.  New York City.  1979  PG 52-53. 

CV detects sub, WaW helps bb drivers to utilize available resources and the risk comes from "going beyond" the detection area. W a W participants can play Great Battle where escorts are used if it is too risky for you in World at War. As a bb driver you milk the exp system in No Torp rooms.

The risk for SS comes at loss due to HH damage, Torp bombers, air depletion/forced surfacing, and many other factors ALREADY in the game dynamics.

Remove the No Torp option.

Capitol - corrected <----

Nice to see that people catch words misspellt.

As for the general gist of your post outside of spelling or grammar usage, just like anything else that requires strategy alteration or behavior modification, removing the No Torp option will add spice to the World at War rooms.

Unless you are just wanting to milk an excessive amount of exp (leveling up gunners and other offensive/attack personnel also used elsewhere in game) without competition from submarines.  Which REALLY is the purpose of No Torp anyways.

Remove the No Torp option.

Mostly bb drivers that enjoy milking the egregious exp are the one's responsible for making no torp rooms. Removing the No Torp option would make the milking a bit more balanced.

Remove the No Torp option.

That is what a No Torp option does. If you are going to play politics, play by the rules. I am well within the guidelines thankyou.